CO129-137 - Sir MacDonnell - 1869 [4-5] — Page 261

CO129 Colonial Office Hong Kong Records 理藩院香港檔案 All AI Reviewed

36

258

39. I therefore, observe with pleasure that, in the interview between Your Lordship and the Memorialists on the 8th of February, Your Lordship expressed anxiety to know whether there was any practical way to the suppression of Gambling in Hongkong by penal means, because the Authorities there said they had exhausted those means and yet failed, whereas the Memorialists asserted that no real attempt had been made to suppress gambling. As all the collateral issues raised in connection with this subject are immaterial in comparison with that raised by Your Lordship, I first rose to examine carefully the positive assertions on that head advanced by the Memorialists, and think that no portion of their case is so weak, capable of direct refutation.

40.

I need scarcely observe, that what difficulty an English Statesman may naturally find in dealing with the revenue derived from gambling Licenses, although such Revenue irreparably arises from efforts to regulate a great evil, thought to be otherwise beyond control, such difficulty partakes rather of sentiment than principle, whereas the open establishment in a British Colony of a system of vicarious punishment, such as that of punishing ten men or a hundred men alike for something done by...

Edit History

2026-05-20 04:06:57 · NVIDIA / meta/llama-4-maverick-17b-128e-instruct
Live
View comparison
AI Proofread
36 258 39. I therefore, observe with pleasure that, in the interview between Your Lordship and the Memorialists on the 8th of February, Your Lordship expressed anxiety to know whether there was any practical way to the suppression of Gambling in Hongkong by penal means, because the Authorities there said they had exhausted those means and yet failed, whereas the Memorialists asserted that no real attempt had been made to suppress gambling. As all the collateral issues raised in connection with this subject are immaterial in comparison with that raised by Your Lordship, I first rose to examine carefully the positive assertions on that head advanced by the Memorialists, and think that no portion of their case is so weak, capable of direct refutation. 40. I need scarcely observe, that what difficulty an English Statesman may naturally find in dealing with the revenue derived from gambling Licenses, although such Revenue irreparably arises from efforts to regulate a great evil, thought to be otherwise beyond control, such difficulty partakes rather of sentiment than principle, whereas the open establishment in a British Colony of a system of vicarious punishment, such as that of punishing ten men or a hundred men alike for something done by...
Baseline (Original)
36 258 39. I therefore, observe with pleasure Your that, in the interview between Ma Lordship and the Memorialists on the best partner was qpt of February, Your Lordship exprepet anxiety to know whether there any practical way to the suppression your of Gambling in Hongtong by prenal means, because the Authorities there said means and they had exhausted those Nice Encl NEA, Extract from London China yet failed, whereas the Memoricelists aferted that no real attempt had been made مارية to supprefs fambling. As all the collatual ipures raised in connection with this subject are immaterial in comparison with that raised by Maur Lordship, first rose to excumine carefully. the pasitive apertions on that head advanced by the Memorialists, and think Main Lardship of their that no portion of متر باشد 40. I will be satisfied case is so weak, capable of direct refutation. arises from I need scarcely observe, that what wer difficulty an English Statesman may naturally find in dealing with the venue Lianses, although derived from gambling Licenses, such Revenue inreprefaility arises effants to regulate a great evil, thought to be otherwise beyond control, such difficulty partatres rather of sentiment than principle, whereas the open establishment in a British bolony of · system of vicarious punishment, such as that of punishing ten men or a hundred men alike for something done a
2026-05-20 04:06:57 · Baseline
View content

36

258

39. I therefore, observe with pleasure

Your that, in the interview between Ma Lordship and the Memorialists on the best partner

was

qpt of February, Your Lordship exprepet

anxiety to know whether there any practical way to the suppression

your

of Gambling in Hongtong by prenal

means,

because the Authorities there said

means and

they had exhausted those

Nice Encl NEA, Extract from London China

yet failed, whereas the Memoricelists aferted that no real attempt had been made

مارية

to supprefs fambling. As all the collatual

ipures raised in connection with this subject

are immaterial in comparison with that raised by Maur Lordship,

first rose to excumine carefully. the pasitive apertions on that head

advanced by the Memorialists, and think Main Lardship

of their

that no portion of

متر باشد

40.

I

will be satisfied

case is so weak,

capable of direct refutation.

arises from

I need scarcely observe, that what wer difficulty an English Statesman may naturally find in dealing with the venue

Lianses, although derived from gambling Licenses, such Revenue inreprefaility arises effants to regulate a great evil, thought to be otherwise beyond control, such difficulty partatres rather of sentiment than principle, whereas the open establishment in a British bolony of

· system of vicarious punishment, such as that of punishing ten men or a hundred men alike for something done

a

Comments

Approved members can add comments, bookmarks, and private notes.

No comments yet.

Private Research Note

Private notes are available after approval.